As most of you know I Redneckcomputergeek hate when some one says you cant do it. Having already set a high bar for my self with Maine Mud Mowers build (See build log here https://www.atltf.com/t1612-been-there-done-that ). I think its time to take a look at the much hated world of hydro's. Now I'm not the first to want to mud a hydro and others have worked on making then faster with pulley swaps and seen mixed results to say the least. But to my knowledge none of them have broken past 12mph let alone the 17 to 20 I hope to hit. So well everyone else was sleeping I got to work.
They say a picture is worth a thousand words but I think video does it much better!
MoWheeler Member
Age : 29 Join date : 2013-10-31 Points : 4107 Posts : 65 Location : Upper sandusky, Ohio
Wouldnt you want the sprockets to be the other way? The large one on the hydro and the small on the live axle? Because the way it is now it would be gear reduced even more and go slower?
Ariens YT11 Established Member
500+ Posts
500+ Posts
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 27 Join date : 2012-10-31 Points : 5164 Posts : 745 Location : The Wyo-Braska Panhandle
Wouldnt you want the sprockets to be the other way? The large one on the hydro and the small on the live axle? Because the way it is now it would be gear reduced even more and go slower?
MoWheeler is correct, the way it is now the gears would be reduced!
MoWheeler Member
Age : 29 Join date : 2013-10-31 Points : 4107 Posts : 65 Location : Upper sandusky, Ohio
Wouldnt you want the sprockets to be the other way? The large one on the hydro and the small on the live axle? Because the way it is now it would be gear reduced even more and go slower?
Ok so now the fact I messed up at the end is out of the way. What do you guys think will it work?
1997 Murray Veteran Member
1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!
2014 Build-Off Finalist
2014 Build-Off Finalist
2015 Build-Off Finalist
2015 Build-Off Finalist
2016 Build-Off Entrant
2016 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 26 Join date : 2013-11-13 Points : 5446 Posts : 1311 Location : NW USA
yes, this should work, we have a scotts hydro, and it is nice to drive, it would be great if it where faster, though. once I got a taste of speed, I wanted more lol.
MoWheeler Member
Age : 29 Join date : 2013-10-31 Points : 4107 Posts : 65 Location : Upper sandusky, Ohio
looks like a solid plan to me, any plans on a oil cooler for the hydro? My prediction is that it will work, but the hydro unit will overheat, and possibly burn up due to it doing 3x the work that it was designed to do. if you can get a cooler/ bigger reservoir to bump up the oil capacity on the hydro it would help the longevity alot. my 2 cents
MoWheeler Member
Age : 29 Join date : 2013-10-31 Points : 4107 Posts : 65 Location : Upper sandusky, Ohio
looks like a solid plan to me, any plans on a oil cooler for the hydro? My prediction is that it will work, but the hydro unit will overheat, and possibly burn up due to it doing 3x the work that it was designed to do. if you can get a cooler/ bigger reservoir to bump up the oil capacity on the hydro it would help the longevity alot. my 2 cents
Yep! ^^^^ Nothing worse than geting your preject done and riding it for a short time only to break it. Believe me... I would know.
Ariens YT11 Established Member
500+ Posts
500+ Posts
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 27 Join date : 2012-10-31 Points : 5164 Posts : 745 Location : The Wyo-Braska Panhandle
looks like a solid plan to me, any plans on a oil cooler for the hydro? My prediction is that it will work, but the hydro unit will overheat, and possibly burn up due to it doing 3x the work that it was designed to do. if you can get a cooler/ bigger reservoir to bump up the oil capacity on the hydro it would help the longevity alot. my 2 cents
on that note, I have a hydro gear 310-510 hydrostatic trans, it will be easy to put a oil cooler on it but I would need a external pump and auto trans cooler off a truck with hose and I need to drill and tap a fitting off the lowest point of the tranny. I can push about 12mph on it but I cant pull any thing at that speed or at all. try pulling a 14'x8' 800lbs trailer with 12 40-50lbs bales and a person on it, I will go up a hill but the 10cc pump in the trans isn't powerfull enough with a 22.2:1 ratio.
1997 Murray Veteran Member
1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!
2014 Build-Off Finalist
2014 Build-Off Finalist
2015 Build-Off Finalist
2015 Build-Off Finalist
2016 Build-Off Entrant
2016 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 26 Join date : 2013-11-13 Points : 5446 Posts : 1311 Location : NW USA
yeah, our scotts hydro stopped working after my dad used it to drag logs up a 100 foot incline (it is so steep that a mower would flip over if you tryed to drive it down there) I had to finish the job with the MTD (after an hour the belts where dead) then the Murray in its former self filled in until its tiers went flat and ITS belt was bunt. (it wasn't long.)
Thunderdivine Veteran Member
1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!
Join date : 2012-12-21 Points : 6543 Posts : 2101 Location : Norway, Europe
also if you have room under the hood??? Try a tranny cooler and e fan stock alternator should do okay with the fan.. or put it on a switch when going over 8-10 flip it on..
I'm watching this one closely to see how it turns out. The theory is pretty sound, indeed. But I'm wondering about side effects. I think with the overdrive, you'd lose a lot of the natural braking a hydro usually offers. I'm also quite interested to see (and it's be better to FEEL it) what it drives like, overall. Will coasting be effect, or even possible? Will it hold up to the strain and possibly heat?
All in all, many of us have thought of or suggested the concept. Hat's off to you for taking the plunge and actually putting it into motion... Literally!
Honestly, I'm not sure that's necessary. Normally, I'd agree. But he's got the drive sprockets located close to the frame points, and the wheel hubs aren't far off that. There isn't much stress on the central part of the axleshaft.
but there is, where is it going to bend first? at the frame or in the middle of the axle? naturally it will want to bend in half, if you ut a bearing in the center of it its going to take alot more of leverage to bend the axle at the frame with about 6 inches of leverage opposed to the whole width of the axle
Doc Sprocket Site VIP
2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
2018 Build-Off Entrant
2018 Build-Off Entrant
2021 Winner of Winners
2021 Winner of Winners
1st Place Build-Off 2016
1st Place Build-Off Winner 2016
Age : 51 Join date : 2013-04-21 Points : 7318 Posts : 2914 Location : Ontario Canada
Well- it's going to want to bend where the forces concentrate- at a leverage point. Generally, just outboard of the frame mounting point (bearing). Ask a guy that has snapped an axle (LOL).
If it were a go kart, or some other arrangement where the drive sprocket were located in the middle of a lot of unsupported axle, I would call it paramount.
But like anything else untried, this will reveal itself.
Mechanically, I'd say it's a sound idea. Since the hydro is not being overspeed on the input, it should not overheat. If you use the hydro to set your gearing, then use the throttle as a gas pedal, it shouldn't see a lot of strain. Driving, I'm not sure how it will run, be interesting to find out. Just don't slam the hydro control on and off, or fwd to reverse.
I think it's a solid idea, and finally somebody is doing it. I know on karts they just add a "doubler" in the center of a long axle, Axle Stiffener but that don't take the strain on long thin axles from the bearing to the wheel hubs, so i would build a = brace in time.
And ofcourse 17mph won't be a problem now, since you do the gearing after the hydro tranny, clever.
redlinemotorsportts Moderator
2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 27 Join date : 2013-03-18 Points : 7483 Posts : 3131 Location : raleigh nc
All i see is that if you put more blocks as close as possible to the rims then theres no need for a center support. hydros can pull a good abount so upping the gearing souldnt hurt it that much. I think going from max speed to stop (decending speed) will be intrusting.