Looks super cool. Great work mr.mod! Interesting about the exhaust drain as well, I would've never thought about the fact that water would enter the exhaust while the engine wasn't running.
"This'll either wake you up or put you to sleep forever!"- Red Green "Whatever you do you should do right, even if it's something wrong." - Hank Hill
Continuing the thought, don't know if it applies to engines, but with guns, when you are underwater, and the barrel is full, it fires just fine. But if you have the end of the barrel in the water, it will fire just fine until it hits the water then the barrel will explode.
IDK if the same principle applies, might want to think about it though.
mr.modified Veteran Member
2015 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2015 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2016 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2016 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2018 Build-Off Finalist
2018 Build-Off Finalist
2022 Build-Off Entrant
2022 Build-Off Entrant
2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
1st Place Build-Off 2014
1st Place Build-Off Winner 2014
2023 Build-Off Entrant
2023 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 34 Join date : 2013-11-02 Points : 7170 Posts : 2910 Location : New Jersey USA
The exhaust should work even a foot or two under water as long as the engine keeps running, but for the most part, only waves would wash over it occasionally. I don't think it will be too much of an issue. I've been in deep water with a tractor and the exhaust just bubbles up through the water.
There's a whole bunch of issues to sort out with this thing. Fairly soon I need to mock up a section of the hull with 1/2" electrical conduit to see if 30" diameter propane tanks are big enough to use.
Thanks. Yeah there should need to be quite a bit of lead added to keep the submarine down far enough in the water that it will work. That will be attached on the bottom to keep the submarine upright. So far I have between 300 and 400 lbs of lead (mostly wheel weights) saved. A wheel weight filled 5 gallon pail is about 100 lbs (roughly).
Any object lighter than the water it displaces will float while any object heavier will sink. Submarines don't really change how much they weigh when they let water into the ballast tanks to sink. A better way to think about it is that they vary their displacement. Depending on the size of the finished machine, it's going to have to weigh between 2500 and 3500 lbs I think.
Forward dive planes. Still needs the linkage rod under the deck. These will be movable on the model.
Forward deck is almost finished
Fake hatch hinge. Could have a rod or pin across it.
One more side to add to the aft deck, then I need to start working on the tail section, propeller, and rudder.
Who knows to be honest. Once I make sure what size hull will work I can try to get some propane tanks. Some are about 30" diameter and some are 35" I think. I was hoping to use the 30" ones.
Also I need a bigger space cleared out at the garage and I have a crane to fix up before I start the actual build.
Oh yeah, being in a steel can 100' under water is kinda risky, don't want to cut corners lol. Thank you.
I am working with a retired engineer on the project but he didn't specialize in pressure vessels. I would like to talk to someone who does if I can find someone. I know about what to do and not to do as far as building the hull. But there are certain things that I might not know. One thing I read is that your not supposed to place a stiffening ring over a circumferential weld in the hull. That is, the internal rings welded inside the hull shouldn't be over a place where you welded two lengths of the hull together. I need to know the best ways to weld fittings through the hull and that sort of thing. Which piece should be over which sometimes makes a difference in strength.
When I get ready to build the actual hull, I will be sure to find out the best way it should be done. I don't want to guess work something like this.
I'm shooting for a max working depth of 100' But with calculated crush depth at far deeper. Maybe 300' or more. Realistically, I won't need to go below 50' very often. There's not much point.
If it implodes I'll be killed instantly lol. So it's a good idea to build it correctly. The good thing is, people have been working on pressure vessel design for over 100 years. So all the info is out there, just need to find out as much as possible and stick to proven ideas.
Hull strength depends on the material used, thickness of the hull, type of stiffening rings used and how far apart they are spaced, diameter of the hull. There's a bunch of stuff. Also any penetration of the hull weakens that area at least somewhat. So things like pipes being welded through or a lever or shaft sticking through, that effects it a bit. The hull thickness can be doubled up around larger weak points. The weakest area would be the part where the hatch and tower goes on. The stiffening rings can't go all the way around there and it's a wide cross section. On other small submarines I have seen, they use a 3/4 or so stiffening ring there with a cross piece joining it to adjacent rings. Here's a pic of what I mean.
The opening marked in blue. The stiffening rings marked in red.
Honestly, since you want to go down 100' I would spend the money and have your design professionally engineered. The pressure and force on the outside of that hull is many times what the atmospheric pressure would be inside the hull. If the hull isn't designed and welded correctly the hull will just crush like a tin can. I would definitely get started by reading up on statics and forces in equilibrium and also ship welding practices like you have been. I would also tour as many ships and submarines as you can and take notes and pictures along the way.
mr.modified Veteran Member
2015 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2015 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2016 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2016 Build-Off Top 3 Winner
2018 Build-Off Finalist
2018 Build-Off Finalist
2022 Build-Off Entrant
2022 Build-Off Entrant
2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
1st Place Build-Off 2014
1st Place Build-Off Winner 2014
2023 Build-Off Entrant
2023 Build-Off Entrant
Age : 34 Join date : 2013-11-02 Points : 7170 Posts : 2910 Location : New Jersey USA
1/2" electrical conduit rings for the full scale skeleton mock up. So far only two done, I'll need about four more this size. These are about 30" diameter.
Yeah I'll make a mock up with the 1/2" pipes and that way I can make sure I will have enough room inside with the size propane tanks I want to use. I have to drive a couple hours to a place where I can buy them I think, so no point in going through a lot of trouble, driving, loading, and paying for the wrong size tanks.
Originally, I thought 30" diameter 250 gallon tanks would do the job. But I forgot to factor in the space the internal stiffening rings would take up inside the boat. With a 2" wide ring, that's 4" diameter taken up inside, leaving me with only 26". I marked that out on some cardboard and right away I could see, that's wayyyyy too small to fit anything in there, let alone bolt things together.
So now, the new plan is to use larger tanks of about 35-37" diameter. With 1.5"-2" stiffening rings, that gives me a good 31"+ to work with inside.
There are other things taking up space inside too, like a floor a couple inches off the bottom to keep you from sitting in the bilge water, pipes, and levers for dive planes and rudder. Some pipes might be able to go under the floor.
Started welding on saddle tanks. On the real one these will be maybe somewhere around 4-7 gallons each at the mid point in the submarine. Changing how much water is in these tanks won't effect the balance or trim of the sub, so fine adjustments of buoyancy can be made without having to re-adjust trim every time.
Other things which need to be on the center line is the 200lb safety drop weight and preferably the fuel tanks. Although the fuel may need to be in two separate tanks under the sub forward and aft.
Aft dive planes welded on. These are in a fixed position. Also in this pic the aft main ballast tank vent can be seen, that's the small pipe that sticks up. On the real one there will be a valve and a linkage rod attached, just like I did with the fwd dive planes and rudder.
slow progress on the submarine model. Forward and aft deck painted. Still one end cap on one of the saddle tanks to weld on and the two port holes in the conning tower.
The laughing sawfish sticker was peeling off my jeep so I taped it on here to see how it would look. Once this model is done, then it's back to work on the full size mock up again to double check that 35" or so diameter will work for the hull. Then, I can actually go buy some tanks.